Eggplant First, Tomato Second: A Tennessee Take on Sicilian Caponata
In my last post, Too Much of a Good Thing, I wrote about trying to keep up with a summer garden while adjusting to a new job. Tomatoes covered the counters, peppers waited to be dealt with, and the eggplants apparently had no sympathy for my schedule.
I shared some of the simplest ways I was using all that produce, but one dish received only a passing mention: caponata. It turned out far too well to leave buried in a list.
The idea had begun a few days earlier, somewhere on the drive home from Nashville. Pino (my husband) had recently made caponata from a recipe he found on the internet, and although I liked it, his version was more tomato-heavy than I wanted mine to be. I wanted to taste the eggplant, peppers, olives, and capers—not have all of them disappear into tomato sauce.
By the time I was ready to make my own, the recipe was taking shape not from a carefully planned shopping list, but from an inventory.
I had two small eggplants, more fresh tomatoes than any reasonable person could need, and colorful lunchbox peppers from the garden. In the refrigerator, I found the dregs of Pino’s caponata supplies: nearly three tablespoons of capers and the last of the green olives. I was not only adapting his idea; I was using his leftovers to do it.
That is often how recipes begin around here.

From Sicily, With Eggplant
Caponata belongs to Sicily, where the bright Mediterranean sun and long growing season produce eggplant, tomatoes, peppers, and herbs much like those filling my own kitchen—along with the olives and capers that give the dish its salty, briny edge.
It is tempting to think of Italian cooking as one unified cuisine, but the food changes considerably as you travel from the cooler, dairy-rich north toward the warmer south. Butter, cream, risotto, polenta, and fresh egg pasta become less dominant. Olive oil, durum-wheat pasta, tomatoes, eggplant, peppers, and other sun-loving vegetables move to the center of the table.
Pino is from Puglia rather than Sicily, but caponata speaks a language familiar throughout southern Italy: olive oil, seasonal vegetables, and the understanding that very good food does not require very many ingredients.
At its heart, caponata is a cooked mixture of eggplant and other vegetables, punctuated with olives and capers and held together by agrodolce—literally “sour-sweet.” Vinegar provides the sharpness; a small amount of sugar softens its edges. The result is savory, salty, tangy, and just sweet enough to keep you going back for another bite.
There is no single caponata guarded unchanged across Sicily. According to Visit Sicily, Palermo’s version is the simplest and most classic, while versions from Agrigento, Catania, Messina, and Trapani may include peppers, potatoes, garlic, honey, raisins, pine nuts, almonds, or different preparations of tomato. La Cucina Italiana says there may be roughly thirty variations across the island.
That was reassuring, because I had departed from anybody’s official recipe before I even turned on the oven.
A Very Busy Stove
I knew I wanted my eggplant to remain the star, so I cut it into chunks and roasted it separately at 425°F. After 20 minutes, it was tender but not quite browned enough, so I gave it another five to ten. The finished pieces were creamy inside and browned around the edges, but still sturdy enough to survive being folded into the other vegetables.
That part was a keeper.

I had no celery, which appears in many traditional versions, but I did have plenty of small red, yellow, and orange lunchbox peppers. I softened the onion first, then cooked the peppers only briefly so they would retain a little bite and provide some of the contrast the missing celery otherwise might have supplied.
Then came the garlic—because I love garlic and remain unconvinced that there is such a thing as too much of it—along with red-pepper flakes bloomed briefly in olive oil.
The chopped fresh tomatoes looked like far too much when they first went into the pan. They immediately released a small lake of juice, which did nothing to relieve my concern that I was recreating the very tomato-heavy caponata I was trying to avoid. But after simmering uncovered, they collapsed and concentrated into a chunky mixture with recognizable pieces still remaining.
At that point I added the whole green olives, capers, red-wine vinegar, and sugar. I tasted it and thought it was delicious, although I was not entirely sure what it was supposed to taste like. It still seemed quite tomatoey—but of course, I was tasting spoonfuls of the tomato mixture before the eggplant had gone in.
Once I folded in the roasted eggplant, everything changed. The tomato stopped being the dish and became the coating around the dish. Glossy pieces of purple-skinned eggplant remained distinct among the whole green olives, capers, colorful peppers, onion, and softened tomato.
That was exactly the balance I had wanted.

I finished it with a drizzle of my good Atlas extra-virgin olive oil. There was no reason to cook away the flavor of that oil when I could add it at the end and actually taste it.
The Great Herb Incident
The caponata was not the only thing happening in my kitchen that day. I also had plain tomatoes roasting, a pan of poblanos, and another pan filled with a Mexican mixture of tomatoes, poblanos, jalapeños, and possibly onions. Half of that mixture eventually went into the freezer. The other half went into the refrigerator, where Pino promptly discovered it.
While the finished caponata waited at the back of the stove, I was peeling the roasted poblanos. They had also cooled more than I intended, which made the skins harder to remove. This was, in other words, not an afternoon characterized by single-minded concentration.
Then I remembered the parsley and basil.

I went outside, gathered what can only be described as a bouquet, brought it in, washed it, dried it, and—following advice that turned out to be somewhat questionable—chopped it rather roughly.
By the time I folded it into the caponata, the mixture was only lukewarm. There was not enough residual heat to soften the herbs or help their flavor settle into the dish. Instead, they remained conspicuously green, leafy, and very much themselves.

Evidently, “too much of a good thing” applies not only to the vegetables taking over the kitchen, but also to the enormous handfuls of fresh herbs I enthusiastically added to the pan.
I decided that next time, I would use about half as much, chop the herbs considerably finer, and fold them in immediately after removing the caponata from the heat.
A Recipe Is Rarely Finished the First Time
Pino liked my less-tomato-heavy caponata, although he still thought it needed tomato paste. The next time he made his, however, he used only half as much, which I considered at least a partial victory.
As it happens, we both moved slightly toward the other’s position. When we made my revised version together, we added two tablespoons of tomato paste—not enough to dominate the vegetables, but enough to give the caponata a deeper, more savory flavor. A few hot banana peppers from the garden joined the sweet lunchbox peppers (use what you have!).
We used fewer herbs, chopped them considerably finer, and folded them in while the caponata was still warm. And although I had left the olives whole in the first batch because they looked beautiful that way, this time we cut each one into two or three pieces so their mild, buttery flavor would find its way into more bites.
Those small changes made an already good caponata even better. The tomato paste added depth without taking over, the herbs became part of the dish instead of sitting conspicuously on top of it, and the olives were better distributed throughout. The caponata pictured on toast is that new-and-improved batch—and it is the version of the recipe I would make again.
This is why I write notes on recipes after I make them.
And while preparing to write this post, I found something unexpected in my recipe files: I had made caponata almost exactly one year earlier. The printed recipe (from a random online source) was dated August 13 and, as is my habit, it was covered with notes. I had added a zucchini, omitted the raisins, and used celery, bell pepper, onion, pine nuts, olives, capers, herbs, hot-pepper flakes, and apparently an entire can of tomato paste.

I remember now that it was pretty good, particularly with the pine nuts, though clearly not memorable enough to survive a year in my head. So much for the romantic story of discovering caponata for the first time.
The version below is not that forgotten recipe, and it is not Pino’s version. It is the version I would make now: eggplant-forward, filled with vegetables from my garden, and revised according to everything I learned after eating my first batch this summer.
We like caponata at room temperature, piled generously onto toasted sourdough bread. It is delicious the day it is made—including by the spoonful directly from the pan while waiting for dinner—but it is even better the next day, after the vinegar, sweetness, olives, capers, garlic, and vegetables have had time to settle into one another.

Heidi’s Roasted Eggplant Caponata
Prep time: approximately 20 minutes
Cook time: approximately 35 minutes
Total time: approximately 55 minutes, plus cooling
Yield: 6–8 servings, depending on how it is served—or 4 if you are Pino
Ingredients
• 2 medium eggplants (about 1 ¾ pounds total), cut into roughly ¾-inch chunks
• Olive oil, for roasting and sautéing
• Salt and freshly ground black pepper
• ½ large yellow onion, diced
• 1 cup diced fresh sweet peppers, such as lunchbox peppers, bell peppers, or a combination, plus 1–2 hot banana peppers, if desired
• 2–3 cloves garlic, minced
• ½ teaspoon red-pepper flakes
• 2 tablespoons tomato paste
• 1½ cups chopped fresh tomatoes, with very watery portions removed if necessary
• ½ cup pitted Castelvetrano olives (the bright green, mild, buttery kind), each cut into 2 or 3 pieces
• 3 tablespoons capers, drained
• 2 tablespoons red-wine vinegar
• 1½ teaspoons sugar
• ¼ cup finely chopped flat-leaf parsley
• 3 tablespoons finely chopped fresh basil
• 1–2 tablespoons good extra-virgin olive oil, for finishing
Instructions
1. Heat the oven to 425°F.
2. Toss the eggplant with enough olive oil to coat it lightly, along with a modest amount of salt and black pepper. Spread it on a sheet pan and roast for 25–30 minutes, turning or stirring once if needed, until the edges are browned and the centers are creamy and tender. The pieces should still hold their shape.
3. Meanwhile, heat about 2 tablespoons of olive oil in a wide skillet over medium heat. Add the onion and cook until soft and translucent, with a few lightly golden edges.
4. Add the diced peppers and cook for 2–3 minutes, until they begin to soften.
5. Add the garlic and red-pepper flakes. Cook for 30–60 seconds, stirring, until fragrant.
6. Add the tomato paste and cook for 1–2 minutes, until it darkens slightly and begins to caramelize in the oil.
7. Add the fresh tomatoes. Simmer uncovered for 8–12 minutes, or until they collapse and their liquid reduces into a chunky, concentrated mixture. Do not cook them into a completely smooth sauce; recognizable pieces of tomato should remain.
8. Stir in the olives, capers, red-wine vinegar, and sugar. Simmer for another 2–3 minutes. Taste before adding any salt—the olives and capers may provide all that is needed.
9. Gently fold in the roasted eggplant. Cook over low heat for 2–3 minutes, just long enough for the flavors to come together. Avoid vigorous stirring so the eggplant remains intact.
10. Remove the skillet from the heat. While the caponata is still quite warm, fold in the finely chopped parsley and basil. Finish with 1–2 tablespoons of good extra-virgin olive oil.
11. Allow the caponata to cool to room temperature before serving. For the best flavor, refrigerate it overnight, then let it return to room temperature before eating. Serve on toasted sourdough bread, alongside a meal, or directly from the pan when no one is looking.
Editor’s note: Nothing says “timely seasonal blogging” quite like publishing a recipe for garden tomatoes and eggplant at the end of October. Consider this an early start on next summer.


Comments